A med spa owner called us in the spring, a little rattled. She had built a lovely membership: a monthly fee that banked toward facials and injectables, a few hundred members, steady money every month that let her finally plan a year ahead. Then one member tried to cancel, could not find a way to do it online, called three times, sat on hold, gave up, and disputed the charge with her bank instead. She also left a one star review that said, in plain words, "easy to join, impossible to quit." That single review sat at the top of the profile for weeks, scaring off people who would have happily signed up.
That is the whole story of practice memberships in 2026 in one phone call. The recurring revenue is real and it is wonderful. But the moment you make leaving hard, the math flips against you fast. And this year, the rules around all of it got genuinely confusing, so a lot of owners have no idea where they actually stand.
First, why so many practices went to memberships
If you run a practice that lives on one time visits, you know the anxiety. You start every month at zero and hope the schedule fills. A membership fixes that. Someone pays every month whether or not they come in, they come back more often because they have already paid, and you can predict next month's revenue instead of praying for it. That is why the model spread everywhere: med spas banking treatments, concierge and direct primary care retainers, weight loss and hormone programs on a monthly plan, dental membership plans for the uninsured, even IV and wellness memberships.
We are big fans of the model when it is built right. We have written before about whether a practice should offer a membership plan and why loyalty programs work for medical practices. The short version is that recurring revenue and retention beat chasing strangers every single month. But the plumbing behind the plan, the sign up and the cancel, is exactly where practices get into trouble.
What actually changed in 2026
Here is the part that has owners confused, so let me lay it out plainly.
Back in 2024 the Federal Trade Commission finalized a national rule on subscriptions and what it calls negative option plans, the kind where a charge keeps happening until someone stops it. The rule got a catchy nickname, click to cancel, and its core idea was simple: cancelling should be at least as easy as signing up. Practices with memberships were squarely in scope.
Then, in July 2025, a federal appeals court stepped in. The Eighth Circuit vacated the rule, meaning it struck it down, on procedural grounds tied to how the FTC wrote it, not because the idea was wrong. So the specific national rule is not in force right now. A lot of practice owners heard "the rule got thrown out" and assumed they were off the hook.
They are not, and here is why. In early 2026 the FTC restarted the whole process, filing a new advance notice of proposed rulemaking and opening it for public comment through the spring. The agency also made clear it will keep going after unfair cancellation practices using laws it already has, like the Restore Online Shoppers Confidence Act and the FTC Act. So the honest status is this: the tidy federal rule is paused and being rewritten, but the enforcement teeth never left.
The rule paused, but the states did not
This is the piece most owners miss. Federal law is not the only law. A growing number of states have their own automatic renewal laws, and some are strict.
California is the clearest example. Its Automatic Renewal Law, tightened again in 2025, spells out what a recurring plan has to do. You have to present the renewal terms clearly and up front. You have to get real consent before the first charge. You have to let people cancel the same easy way they signed up, and you specifically cannot force a patient to get on the phone with a person to do it. You have to send annual reminders of what they are paying and how to cancel. And you have to give notice, generally at least seven days, before any price change takes effect. New York, Virginia, and others have their own versions, and more are coming.
So even with the federal rule on ice, if a single member of yours lives in a state with a law like California's, you are bound by it. If you run a group with locations in more than one state, or you ever plan to grow, the safe move is to build to the strictest standard and be done worrying about it. You can read California's own consumer guidance straight from the state's Attorney General if you want the source.
Why the smart owners make cancelling easy on purpose
Now the part that matters more than any rule. Set the law aside for a second and just look at the numbers.
When you make cancelling hard to squeeze one more payment out of someone, you are not really keeping the money. You are trading a small, angry refund for a much bigger bill. That member disputes the charge, so your merchant account eats a chargeback fee and your dispute ratio climbs, which can put your whole payment processing at risk if it happens enough. They tell friends. And they leave the review, the one that costs you not one membership but every future patient who reads it and picks someone else instead. We put real numbers on that in how much a bad review costs a medical practice, and it is more than most owners think.
There is a hidden cost too. A hard exit does not just anger the people leaving, it scares the people thinking about joining. The single biggest reason a patient hesitates on a membership is the fear of being trapped. When your terms clearly say you can cancel anytime, online, in a minute, you remove that fear and more people say yes at the start. Easy out, more in. That is not a compliance headache, that is a conversion strategy.
The two minute test
Open your own website on your phone, as a patient would, and try to cancel your membership. Not call, not email, cancel. If you cannot find a clear way to do it in under two minutes without talking to your front desk, your patients cannot either, and that is your leak, your review risk, and your compliance gap all in one place. Fix that screen before you spend another dollar getting people to the sign up screen.
What a clean, patient friendly membership looks like
You do not need a lawyer on retainer to get this mostly right. A membership that keeps you safe and actually grows looks like this:
- Plain terms at sign up. The price and how often it renews, in normal words, right next to the button. Not a wall of fine print, not a graphic Google cannot read, plain text a nervous person can understand in five seconds.
- Real consent before the first charge. A clear checkbox or confirmation, not a pre ticked box or a charge that sneaks in after a free trial with no warning.
- A welcome that restates the deal. An email or text that says what they bought, what they pay, when it renews, and how to cancel. Clarity now prevents disputes later.
- An annual reminder. Once a year, tell them what they are paying and how to stop. It feels generous. It is also required in some states.
- Notice before any price change. If the fee goes up, tell them ahead of time and let them opt out. Surprise price bumps are how good members turn into public complaints.
- A cancel they can do themselves. Same channel they joined through, online, without a phone gauntlet. Offer a pause instead of a hard stop, and you will save more members than any hold music ever did.
Where EtherealMinds fits in
Most of these problems are not legal problems, they are website and system problems, and that is our lane. When we build a med spa website or a concierge and membership practice website, we put the terms where people can actually read them, wire up a clean sign up, and make cancelling and pausing something a patient can do without cornering your front desk. The result is fewer disputes, fewer angry reviews, and more people willing to join because the exit is not scary.
Then we do the part that grows the thing. Our patient acquisition system for med spas and other membership practices markets the plan honestly, brings the right people in, and keeps your reputation clean so one bad cancellation experience does not undo a month of good marketing. The membership is only worth building if it fills. We build it so it does, and so it holds up when a regulator, a bank, or a Google reviewer takes a closer look.
Our honest take
The click to cancel saga will keep bouncing around courts and agencies, and honestly, you should not build your business around whichever way it lands this quarter. Build around the thing that is true no matter what the rule says: patients reward practices that treat them fairly and punish the ones that trap them. Make joining clear, make leaving easy, remind people what they pay, and never surprise them on price. Do that and the law takes care of itself, the reviews stay kind, and the memberships you keep are the ones you actually earned. That is a better business than one held together by hold music.
Not sure if your membership holds up?
Book a free strategy call. We will look at how your plan signs people up, renews them, and lets them leave, flag anything that could cost you a chargeback or a review, and build a clean, patient friendly version that grows instead of leaks. No jargon, no scare tactics, just a membership you can be proud to sell.
Book a free strategy call →