A dermatology office called us frustrated last spring. They had a beautiful email newsletter, sent every month, packed with skin tips and seasonal specials. Open rate: around 11 percent. Meanwhile their front desk was spending hours a day on the phone reminding people about appointments, and they were still eating a pile of no shows every week. The owner asked the question we hear constantly: should we just text patients instead of emailing them?
It is a fair question, and the honest answer is not one or the other. Text and email do different jobs. Get the split right and you fill more chairs, lose fewer patients, and stop drowning your front desk in phone tag. Get it wrong and you either annoy people or talk into the void. So let us break it down with real numbers.
The open rate gap is not close
Start with the single most important fact. People read texts. They mostly ignore email.
Text messages get opened about 98 percent of the time, compared to roughly a 20 percent open rate for email, according to SMS marketing statistics compiled for 2025. And it is faster too: on average people respond to a text within about 90 seconds, versus around 90 minutes for email. In healthcare the email gap is even wider. Some reports put healthcare email open rates as low as 12 percent, while a strong majority of patients say they read text messages from their providers.
So if a message absolutely has to be seen, a reminder, a confirmation, a last minute opening, it should be a text. Email alone is a gamble on something time sensitive.
Where text wins: reminders, confirmations, and no shows
The clearest, highest return use of texting is the appointment reminder. This is not a small tweak. It is one of the best returns on effort a practice can find.
A large study from Imperial College London found that no show rates were 38 percent lower among patients who received a text reminder, as reported in this write up on text reminders and no shows. Broader reviews land in a similar range, with text reminders cutting missed appointments by roughly 30 to 50 percent. Put that next to the cost of a single no show, often around 200 dollars in wasted provider time, and a reminder that costs a few cents becomes a no brainer.
Texting also shines for the quick, two way stuff:
- Appointment confirmations where the patient just replies to confirm or reschedule.
- Waitlist and last minute openings. A cancellation at 9am can be filled by noon if you can text five people who wanted an earlier slot.
- Recall and reactivation. "It has been a year since your last visit, want us to hold a spot?" gets read, where the same email dies in a promotions folder. We dug into this in how to reactivate past patients and leads.
- Simple logistics. Running late, parking, what to bring, where to check in.
The pattern is: short, urgent, needs a fast reply. That is text territory. If you are still doing all of this by phone, you are paying staff to play voicemail tag for messages that a text would settle in seconds. We covered the front desk side of this in how to turn phone calls into booked patients.
Why patients really prefer text
Nobody wants to call the office, sit on hold, explain themselves to a stranger, and hope they wrote the time down right. A text is on their terms. They read it between meetings, reply while waiting for coffee, and never worry they interrupted anything. That is not a marketing trick. It is just how people communicate now. Meeting patients where they already are is the whole game.
Where email still wins: the long stuff worth saving
Email is not dead, it just has a narrower job. It is the right home for anything long, visual, or worth keeping. A text is a Post it note. An email is a folder.
Use email for:
- New patient welcome packets and intake forms. Room to explain, attach forms, and let the patient fill things out before they arrive. See what to send new patients before the first visit.
- Detailed prep and aftercare instructions. Pre procedure dos and donts, recovery timelines, medication notes. Things patients want to search for later.
- Newsletters and health education. Seasonal tips, new services, staff introductions. Low urgency, higher depth.
- Receipts, statements, and paperwork the patient may need to find again months from now.
The tradeoff is right there in the open rate: most of this will not get read immediately, and some never gets read at all. So the rule is simple. Never make email the only channel for anything the patient must see before a deadline. Email is the library. Text is the doorbell. When something in the library really matters, ring the doorbell: send a short text that says "just emailed your pre visit instructions, check your inbox." That one move rescues a huge share of important emails.
The HIPAA part, without the fear
Here is where a lot of owners freeze up. Can you even text patients legally? Yes, with the right setup. The mistake is casual texting from a personal phone, where messages are unencrypted and the practice keeps no record. HIPAA guidance allows plain SMS only when a patient has asked for it and been told it is not fully secure.
The safer path is a dedicated business texting platform tied to your practice number. It gets consent, keeps a log, honors opt outs, and lets you keep the sensitive details out of the message itself. In practice that means a reminder can say "you have an appointment Thursday at 2 with Dr. Lee" without naming a diagnosis, and anything genuinely private moves to a secure portal message. Get consent, keep it minimal, keep a record, honor stop requests. That is the whole game. We laid out the details in is it legal to text patients, and the flip side, why medical practice emails go to spam, is worth a read before you lean too hard on email.
The hidden cost of doing neither well
A lot of practices send reminders by phone, a newsletter by email that nobody opens, and nothing at all to the patients who drifted away. Then they spend real money on ads to replace patients they already had. Fixing your text and email flow is often cheaper than buying new patients, because it saves the ones you worked to earn. Retention is the marketing nobody brags about.
So, text or email? Use both, on purpose
The answer is not to pick a side. It is to give each channel the job it is good at, and let the patient choose their preference. A simple split that works for almost every practice:
- Text reminders, confirmations, waitlist offers, recall nudges, and quick logistics. Anything short and time sensitive.
- Email welcome packets, detailed instructions, newsletters, and paperwork. Anything long and worth saving.
- Text as the nudge for email whenever an email really matters.
- Always get consent, keep records, and honor opt outs on both.
Do that and two things happen. Your no shows drop, because reminders actually get read. And your relationship with existing patients gets stronger, because the right message reaches them in the right place instead of shouting into an inbox they never open.
How EtherealMinds helps
Most practices do not have a texting problem or an email problem. They have a system problem: messages going out by hand, no consent tracking, no reminders on autopilot, and no plan for the patients who drift away. When we build a patient acquisition and retention system for a practice, patient communication is baked in: automated text reminders that cut no shows, recall and reactivation flows that bring old patients back, email for the longer content, and consent and opt outs handled for you. It runs off one platform tied to your practice number, so your front desk stops playing phone tag and every patient hears from you in the channel they actually read. For practices leaning on social and ads to grow, our social media management feeds the top of that funnel while text and email hold onto the patients it earns.
Turn reminders into show ups and patients into regulars
Book a free strategy call. We will look at how your practice talks to patients today, show you where messages are getting missed, and map out a text and email setup that fills more chairs without adding work for your front desk.
Book a free strategy call →